Born in South Bend, Replogle and his family moved to Fort Wayne where he graduated from Snider in 1972. Replogle pitched for two seasons for the Milwaukee Brewers, going 9-5 with a 3.92 ERA in 1978. He started 18 games that season with three complete games and two shutouts, striking out 41 batters in 1491/3 innings. He made his major-league debut on April 11, 1978, against the Yankees at County Stadium, facing one batter in relief and giving up a hit. Replogle went on to pitch in 32 games that season. His final game in the majors was Sept.30, 1979.